This Is My Faith - Al-fatlawi, Ali - الصفحة ٢٥٨ - the Imams (PBUT)?
Hasan: Very good. Besides, the Almighty Allah can never link the obedience to Himself and His Messenger (PBUH) with sinful people in authority. That would definitely be an inconsistency.
Anwar: Very good. However, there are believers who are in power like Faqih or Mujtahid – religious experts or scholars – and they are not infallible. How about them?
Hasan: The religious scholars (Faqih), as a matter of fact, follow the infallible Imams (PBUT), and so obeying them is part of obeying the infallible (PBUT), not to mention that they are appointed by the infallible (PBUH) and that they utter nothing but their words. Besides, ‘the people in authority’ – of course, only the infallible (PBUT) – have the right to order and rule, and the Faqih practice this right as successors of the infallible (PBUT) and we must obey them as well.
Anwar: In view of this, are we obliged to love the Imams (PBUT) in the same degree that we obey them? In other words, are we sinful if we neither love them nor hate them?
Hasan: Before we pass a judgment the affectionate or